Tasting notes
526 bottlings
Every note carries nose, palate and finish as three separate movements, and every taster is shown scoring individually. Four people disagreeing about a whisky tells you more than one averaged number ever will. Notes by WHISKY:EDITION.
526 of 526
Tobermory
5 yr
52.6%
68
Glenburgie
9 yr
50%
74
Brora
20 yr
54.9%
93
Nc'Nean
—
48.5%
81
Dalmore
10 yr
55.6%
75
Littlemill
25 yr
52.8%
89
Springbank
26 yr
44.9%
88
Bunnahabhain
31 yr
44.7%
89
Talisker
24 yr
43%
90
Steinhauser
10 yr
53.2%
82
Steinhauser
5 yr
58%
90
St. Kilian
4 yr
50.7%
79
St. Kilian
6 yr
58.8%
84
St. Kilian
—
54.6%
86
St. Kilian
6 yr
55.5%
84
Aberfeldy
25 yr
46%
87
St. Kilian
—
46%
76
St. Kilian
—
46%
72
Invergordon
35 yr
48.1%
78
Benromach
11 yr
46%
76
Benromach
12 yr
46%
76
Benromach
9 yr
46%
81
Kavalan
—
40%
82
Destillerie Kammer-Kirsch + Rothaus
8 yr
41%
74
Farny Destillerie
5 yr
43%
68
Hercynian Distilling Co.
—
46%
80
Tormore
10 yr
48%
74
Ardbeg
10 yr
61.7%
86
Thousand Mountains
4 yr
58%
81
Tormore
10 yr
48%
78
Longmorn
19 yr
53.9%
87
Glencadam
15 yr
46%
77
Kavalan
—
57.8%
86
Glenfiddich
—
43%
68
Unknown
15 yr
43%
78
Bunnahabhain
11 yr
43%
76
Tobermory
17 yr
56.5%
89
Nc'Nean
—
59.3%
85
Talisker
9 yr
50%
79
Daftmill
15 yr
55.7%
79
Tamnavulin
11 yr
57.4%
82
Midleton
21 yr
46%
89
BenRiach
21 yr
46%
88
Isle of Jura
30 yr
46%
79
Teeling
21 yr
46%
87
Caol Ila
11 yr
47.5%
80
Mortlach
25 yr
46%
87
Linkwood
25 yr
46%
85
BenRiach
25 yr
46%
87
Glenfarclas
21 yr
43%
82
St. Kilian
—
53.4%
86
Glencadam
—
46%
74
St. Kilian
—
59.7%
80
St. Kilian
—
51.1%
77
Deanston
12 yr
57.8%
82
GlenAllachie
10 yr
57.2%
87
Nikka
—
43%
75
Midleton
—
40%
69
12 yr
55.5%
87
Lochranza
25 yr
46%
86
Destilería y Bodega Abasolo
—
43%
67
Wieser
7 yr
40%
73
St. Kilian
—
56.1%
81
Schlitzer Korn- & Edelobstbrennerei GmbH
—
43%
54
Nc'Nean
7 yr
60.1%
82
Corby Spirit and Wine Ltd.
—
43%
71
St. Kilian
—
54%
81
High West Distillery
—
46%
75
Fettercairn
—
47.8%
85
St. Kilian
—
55.3%
82
Laphroaig
34 yr
51.7%
91
Cameronbridge
14 yr
50.3%
85
Longmorn
40 yr
46.7%
89
Strathisla
24 yr
56.2%
95
GORFH Merdingen
7 yr
48%
81
Royal Brackla
11 yr
46%
73
Northoff Feinbrennerei
11 yr
63.5%
86
Glen Ord
10 yr
46%
76
Gammelstilla
7 yr
53.5%
80
—
44.2%
76
Longmorn
11 yr
52.4%
84
Royal Brackla
10 yr
55.3%
86
Northoff Feinbrennerei
10 yr
56.5%
80
Northoff Feinbrennerei
4 yr
59.1%
82
Tormore
10 yr
48%
76
Ardmore
12 yr
60.7%
80
13 yr
55.5%
81
—
46%
75
InchDairnie
8 yr
57.9%
85
Aberfeldy
40 yr
47.2%
93
Wolfburn
12 yr
46%
79
Pulteney
12 yr
40%
70
—
40%
63
Glen Moray
14 yr
56.3%
81
Oban
—
50.8%
86
Blackwater
—
48.5%
79
Skellig Six18 Distillery
6 yr
58.7%
82
Great Northern
8 yr
55.2%
79
Great Northern
—
46%
75
St. Kilian
—
57.8%
81
St. Kilian
—
47%
78
St. Kilian
—
53.5%
82
St. Kilian
6 yr
58.9%
82
St. Kilian
—
46%
74
Tobermory
17 yr
56.5%
86
Nc'Nean
—
61.1%
83
Talisker
—
45.8%
79
Langatun
5 yr
40%
61
Tomatin
—
43%
73
Bruichladdich
31 yr
50.6%
86
Glenburgie
24 yr
55.2%
89
Lochranza
24 yr
44.7%
90
Nc'Nean
—
46%
71
Mortlach
—
57.5%
77
Ben Nevis
24 yr
43.9%
78
Caol Ila
11 yr
57.3%
84
14 yr
50.6%
82
Teaninich
7 yr
60.2%
72
Allt-a-Bhainne
14 yr
64.4%
87
Glen Spey
7 yr
60.1%
75
7 yr
55.3%
79
Glendronach
—
58.2%
85
Royal Brackla
12 yr
40%
79
M&H
—
61.2%
86
Talisker
8 yr
58.7%
88
GlenAllachie
14 yr
62.4%
86
Glenlivet
13 yr
40%
78
St. Kilian
—
59.5%
79
Braeval
—
44.5%
87
Stauning
—
47.8%
81
Lambertus Bräu und Brand
12 yr
56.6%
83
Lambertus Bräu und Brand
12 yr
40%
78
Wolfburn
—
58%
84
Wolfburn
8 yr
46%
80
Wolfburn
8 yr
50%
78
Wolfburn
10 yr
46%
81
Wolfburn
8 yr
50%
81
Glen Garioch
21 yr
53.9%
90
St. Kilian
6 yr
58.9%
82
Ardmore
12 yr
56.2%
74
13 yr
56.9%
86
St. Kilian
—
48%
79
Nc'Nean
—
46%
79
Highland Park
13 yr
57.7%
84
Jim Beam
8 yr
53.5%
86
St. Kilian
—
60.9%
80
Glen Moray
7 yr
62%
69
17 yr
53.7%
81
St. Kilian
4 yr
50.7%
80
Inchgower
12 yr
57.6%
71
Balblair
33 yr
62.3%
90
Ardbeg
7 yr
57.1%
84
Speyside Distillery
15 yr
46%
79
Tomatin
17 yr
46%
82
Tobermory
12 yr
46.3%
78
Nikka
—
45%
75
Bruichladdich
18 yr
54.3%
86
St. Kilian
—
57.6%
84
Northoff Feinbrennerei
10 yr
69.6%
86
21 yr
49.7%
85
Glenlossie
19 yr
46%
77
St. Kilian
—
46%
72
Schroll
—
45%
78
Nc'Nean
—
48.5%
81
Caperdonich
27 yr
52.1%
81
St. Kilian
—
60.6%
82
Allt-a-Bhainne
10 yr
59.1%
74
St. Kilian
—
49.8%
79
Bruichladdich
13 yr
58.1%
84
Nc'Nean
6 yr
54.3%
82
Glen Elgin
—
58.7%
69
Tobermory
16 yr
66.1%
86
Craigellachie
10 yr
67.4%
86
GlenAllachie
12 yr
66.4%
75
Ardnamurchan
—
46.8%
82
HeiligenBergFeld
—
60.2%
74
Benrinnes
21 yr
55.4%
89
Talisker
—
45.8%
76
Bruichladdich
30 yr
45.8%
91
Benromach
40 yr
56.5%
91
St. Kilian
—
54%
83
Nikka
—
45%
71
—
45%
76
Glen Moray
—
40%
77
Woodford Reserve
—
45.2%
78
Woodford Reserve
—
43.2%
74
Tomatin
—
43%
76
St. George's Distillery
9 yr
67.3%
81
Puni
4 yr
46%
77
Ben Nevis
10 yr
67.3%
80
—
53.7%
82
Ballindalloch
8 yr
60.8%
79
Glen Scotia
14 yr
56.8%
79
Kingsbarns
—
46%
79
Glengyle
8 yr
57.4%
83
Deanston
12 yr
46.3%
81
Teeling
—
46%
77
Roseisle
12 yr
55.6%
82
—
43%
78
Talisker
—
48.6%
81
Lagavulin
12 yr
57.4%
82
Highland Park
18 yr
52%
87
Nc'Nean
—
59.6%
83
Midleton
—
40%
72
Hausbrauerei Altstadthof
—
43.2%
80
Glenturret
12 yr
46.4%
79
Glenfiddich
23 yr
47.2%
85
21 yr
53.6%
86
HeiligenBergFeld
—
57.8%
79
—
56%
86
—
56.2%
86
Tormore
12 yr
66.8%
81
Auchroisk
12 yr
60.8%
72
HeiligenBergFeld
3 yr
57.9%
74
Craigellachie
—
61.2%
83
6 yr
46.4%
79
Lagavulin
11 yr
46%
79
St. Kilian
—
50.8%
83
Bruichladdich
14 yr
56.2%
83
Glenturret
—
44%
76
18 yr
40%
73
Nc'Nean
—
48.5%
77
The Balvenie
14 yr
47.8%
84
Kilchoman
—
57%
79
—
51%
88
—
49%
84
Cameronbridge
34 yr
54.9%
84
Nc'Nean
—
48.5%
78
Bowmore
10 yr
58.4%
81
Glenfarclas
—
46%
88
40 yr
41.2%
85
Ardbeg
19 yr
42%
84
Tobermory
18 yr
41%
79
15 yr
46%
83
Glenturret
—
55.6%
83
Macallan
20 yr
58.3%
88
GlenAllachie
5 yr
48%
84
Betz Manufaktur
5 yr
43%
62
Betz Manufaktur
4 yr
48%
52
Betz Manufaktur
4 yr
43%
60
Betz Manufaktur
—
46%
62
Edradour
19 yr
55%
87
Glenlivet
—
59.8%
79
North British
31 yr
46.7%
83
Macallan
20 yr
59.4%
90
Aberfeldy
18 yr
43%
87
Deanston
11 yr
55.7%
89
Edradour
12 yr
46%
83
Lantenhammer
5 yr
50.1%
78
—
49%
86
St. Kilian
5 yr
57.4%
77
Macallan
12 yr
40%
77
Ardmore
15 yr
57.9%
78
Miyagikyo
—
45%
79
Northoff Feinbrennerei
10 yr
64.1%
90
St. Kilian
—
49%
76
St. Kilian
—
59.1%
82
Knockdhu
18 yr
46%
83
Ben Nevis
10 yr
58.9%
85
Teaninich
11 yr
48.3%
79
St. George's Distillery
—
48.7%
81
Dailuaine
10 yr
57.1%
80
Hercynian Distilling Co. / Hammerschmiede
—
43%
72
Ardmore
13 yr
59%
80
Glenfiddich
—
40%
65
Glenturret
29 yr
42.1%
79
Glenfiddich
—
40%
63
Betz Manufaktur
5 yr
51%
57
Allt-a-Bhainne
17 yr
60.1%
81
Royal Brackla
10 yr
46%
82
Caol Ila
9 yr
54.9%
83
Craigellachie
—
54%
90
Miyagikyo
—
47%
80
Nishinomiya, Miyagikyo, Moji, Satsumatsukasa
—
48%
78
Yoichi
—
45%
78
Four Roses
—
50%
71
Glen Moray
19 yr
54.8%
71
Scheibel Mühle
—
58.7%
66
Glenlivet
12 yr
40%
73
Lindores
—
46%
73
St. Kilian
—
58.7%
82
—
46.8%
74
St. Kilian
3 yr
48%
73
Northoff Feinbrennerei
7 yr
53.1%
80
Finch
8 yr
42%
72
Teaninich
13 yr
46%
73
—
46%
85
Number Nine
10 yr
46%
79
Warenghem
—
42%
58
Teeling
21 yr
46%
88
Bimmerle
—
42%
72
Bimmerle
—
40%
70
Tomintoul
14 yr
46%
68
Glen Moray
12 yr
57.83%
79
Kloster Dalheim
4 yr
40%
68
Glenrothes
—
57%
80
Teeling
—
46%
71
Hercynian Distilling Co. / Hammerschmiede
—
60.6%
84
Glenalba
25 yr
41.4%
76
—
46.2%
73
Höhler
10 yr
64.7%
79
Stauning
3 yr
62.2%
71
Stauning
4 yr
45.8%
62
Isle of Jura
10 yr
40%
64
Teeling
—
50%
81
Dailuaine
9 yr
59.2%
69
Bercloux
—
46%
74
Miltonduff
11 yr
46%
69
Kavalan
—
57.8%
89
—
46%
75
Balcones
—
53%
78
Speyburn
16 yr
43%
66
Benromach
10 yr
43%
83
Balcones
6 yr
55.2%
77
Hardenberg
5 yr
43%
65
Early Times
—
43%
71
—
46%
82
St. Kilian
8 yr
58.3%
81
—
50%
90
Teeling
—
46%
71
Fettercairn
16 yr
46.4%
78
Glenfarclas
15 yr
46%
80
Acha
12 yr
43%
77
10 yr
59.1%
83
23 yr
44%
79
Three Ships
12 yr
46.3%
78
GlenAllachie
9 yr
48%
81
GlenAllachie
9 yr
48%
78
GlenAllachie
9 yr
48%
79
Agitator Whiskymakare
—
43%
76
—
51%
82
St. Kilian
4 yr
53.3%
81
Glentauchers
11 yr
57.1%
83
—
53.8%
86
De Tweekoppige Phoenix
5 yr
44.7%
62
Laphroaig
10 yr
52.4%
82
Mannochmore
—
44.5%
65
Northoff Feinbrennerei
12 yr
62.5%
80
Lagavulin
8 yr
48%
83
Royal Brackla
12 yr
58.1%
79
Waterford
—
50%
82
St. Kilian
5 yr
58.4%
83
Miyagikyo, Yoichi
—
40%
62
Balcones
—
53%
79
8 yr
45.8%
70
Isle of Raasay
—
46.6%
83
Balcones
—
46%
72
Wolfburn
—
46%
69
Isle of Raasay
—
46.4%
77
Springbank
15 yr
54.2%
84
M&H
—
59.9%
75
Glenlivet
—
40%
73
Henrich
7 yr
46.4%
75
Kavalan
—
57.1%
86
Fettercairn
—
50.6%
73
Glen Moray
10 yr
40%
76
Glen Scotia
10 yr
40%
67
Tamdhu
18 yr
46.8%
83
Northoff Feinbrennerei
7 yr
58%
85
Glenrothes
12 yr
56.6%
86
Balcones
—
46%
77
GlenAllachie
8 yr
46%
78
Balmenach
8 yr
54.2%
85
Cardhu
18 yr
40%
76
Springbank
—
46%
77
10 yr
46%
74
Northoff Feinbrennerei
8 yr
53.9%
84
Glenturret
12 yr
56.4%
81
St. Kilian
5 yr
62.1%
75
Penderyn
—
41%
71
Penderyn
—
41%
73
Penderyn
—
41%
73
Owensboro
3 yr
59.9%
82
Balcones
—
50%
69
Torabhaig
—
46%
81
Begatal
5 yr
40%
19
Loch Lomond
18 yr
46%
82
Springbank
15 yr
46%
85
Springbank
10 yr
46%
80
Midleton
—
40%
76
Henrich
10 yr
60.1%
84
Port Ellen
—
58.1%
93
Springbank
—
46%
81
Bunnahabhain
12 yr
46.3%
83
Blair Athol
9 yr
57.1%
79
Lochlea
5 yr
50%
83
Heimatverein Wünnenberg e.V.
—
46%
65
Deanston
11 yr
54.8%
83
Talisker
18 yr
45.8%
91
Four Roses
—
45%
72
Glenlossie
12 yr
57.3%
85
Mavela
—
42%
74
Benrinnes
12 yr
57.2%
81
Benrinnes
15 yr
56.4%
85
Tullibardine
—
43%
64
Tullibardine
—
43%
69
Tullibardine
—
43%
65
Tullibardine
—
43%
60
Tullibardine
8 yr
57.1%
83
GORFH Merdingen
4 yr
43.5%
74
Blair Athol
11 yr
54%
80
12 yr
40%
66
Ben Nevis
10 yr
57.4%
84
Pulteney
18 yr
46%
84
Buffalo Trace
10 yr
45%
80
Oban
11 yr
53.8%
87
Glenmorangie
14 yr
46%
78
Freespirited Drinks AG
—
—
1
—
46.2%
80
10 yr
40%
78
Glen Moray
15 yr
40%
76
—
46%
72
Midleton
—
46%
82
Midleton
—
40%
71
Tormore
14 yr
61.6%
81
Buffalo Trace
—
45%
78
Buffalo Trace
—
40%
68
—
43%
74
Talisker
—
45.8%
73
Jack Daniel's
4 yr
50%
74
10 yr
46%
80
Knockdhu
12 yr
40%
80
Glengyle
12 yr
46%
78
Ardnamurchan
—
58.2%
85
Northoff Feinbrennerei
10 yr
53.3%
88
Dailuaine
10 yr
55.6%
84
Craigellachie
13 yr
46%
78
Jim Beam
6 yr
62.95%
88
Glenrothes
26 yr
50.5%
90
Bulleit Distilling Company
—
45%
75
Lochlea
—
60.1%
84
Lochranza
10 yr
46%
85
Northoff Feinbrennerei
5 yr
55.8%
83
Northoff Feinbrennerei
6 yr
52.9%
84
Lochlea
—
46%
69
—
48%
79
Aberfeldy
12 yr
40%
66
—
45.5%
76
Dalmore
—
40%
55
Ardnamurchan
—
46.8%
79
Kloster Dalheim
4 yr
46%
73
St. Kilian
4 yr
53.9%
80
Dalwhinnie
15 yr
43%
64
Penderyn
—
46%
74
Midleton
12 yr
58.1%
90
Glendronach
8 yr
46%
81
Laphroaig
—
48%
83
Famous Grouse
—
40%
60
Tomintoul
16 yr
40%
76
Blair Athol
10 yr
46%
66
Glenglassaugh
8 yr
47.3%
85
The Balvenie
15 yr
43%
80
Jack Daniel's
—
45%
71
Bruichladdich
—
50%
82
Glen Keith
21 yr
43%
84
Macduff
20 yr
40%
70
Speyburn
18 yr
46%
81
Kloster Dalheim
4 yr
46%
72
Aultmore
13 yr
57.4%
86
Kloster Dalheim
5 yr
58%
76
Ardbeg
—
51.7%
76
Lochlea
3 yr
46%
80
Glenturret
30 yr
45.3%
92
Wild Turkey
—
58.4%
86
Wild Turkey
—
50.5%
79
Midleton
12 yr
40%
84
Cardhu
12 yr
40%
60
Knockando
12 yr
43%
66
Stork Club
—
45%
68
Glen Scotia
—
46%
85
The Balvenie
12 yr
40%
83
Clynelish
14 yr
46%
79
—
46%
80
Talisker
—
45.8%
84
Cedar Ridge Distillery
3 yr
45%
75
St. Kilian
3 yr
55.3%
82
Bulleit Distilling Company
10 yr
45.6%
84
—
40%
61
Glen Elgin
12 yr
43%
74
Suntory Yamazaki
—
43%
77
—
40%
59
North British
15 yr
46%
69
Oban
14 yr
43%
78
Lagavulin
11 yr
46%
82
Norrtelje Brenneri AB
7 yr
46.3%
60
Lochlea
3 yr
46%
80
Talisker
10 yr
45.8%
82
Caol Ila
12 yr
43%
75
Royal Lochnagar
12 yr
40%
70
Cragganmore
12 yr
40%
71
Glenkinchie
12 yr
43%
71
—
46.8%
67
Dufftown
12 yr
40%
69
Kavalan
—
56.3%
89
—
40%
50
—
44.2%
75
Ardbeg
—
46.6%
79
Ardmore
12 yr
46%
67
Lochlea
—
46%
77
St. Kilian
—
49%
79
13 yr
56.2%
85
Starward
—
40%
79
Mackmyra
—
46.1%
80
Midleton
15 yr
46%
87
12 yr
40%
60
Ardbeg
—
50.1%
74
Ardbeg
—
57.1%
84
Ardbeg
5 yr
47.4%
80
Annandale
—
60.6%
81
Bunnahabhain
—
46.3%
80
Lagavulin
16 yr
43%
91
Mackmyra
—
46.1%
68
Kavalan
—
40%
69
Knockando
15 yr
43%
71
Glenmorangie
10 yr
40%
72
Dingle
—
46.3%
76
Bruichladdich
6 yr
61.3%
87
Glenfiddich
12 yr
40%
68
12 yr
40%
61
Paul John
—
48%
79
Nikka
—
51.4%
77
Kinahans
—
43%
73
Starward
3 yr
48%
65
Highland Park
15 yr
44%
69
Hercynian Distilling Co. / Hammerschmiede
—
43%
81
Bimber
12 yr
46.3%
69