Tasting notes

Dun Naomhaig Bay Batch 1 (2022) - Feinkost Reifferscheid

The 2022 single malt whisky, bottled by Feinkost Reifferscheid, hails from Scotland's Isle of Islay, a region renowned for its robust and smoky whiskies. As an independent bottler, Feinkost Reifferscheid has once again demonstrated its expertise with this release.

The panel

Marcel
85
Sascha
87

Mean 86.0 · spread 2

Value for money 5/5

Bottler
Feinkost Reifferscheid
Type
Single Malt
Region
Isle of Islay
Country
Scotland
Strength
56.2% ABV
Character
spicy

Tasting

Nose

Upon the first nosing, intense aromas of ashy, cold campfire smoke emerge, accompanied by earthy notes. A subtle sweetness of honey and vanilla harmonizes with a pronounced sea breeze reminiscent of salty seawater. This combination imparts deep complexity and authenticity to the whisky.

Palate

On the palate, the whisky is oily and full-bodied. Fresh citrus notes, especially lemon zest, meet chalky hints and a touch of medicinal iodine, reminiscent of bandages. The voluminous smoke is complemented by nuances of heather and a slight nuttiness, adding depth and complexity to the whisky.

Finish

The finish is medium-length, characterized by a salty, seawater-like note. A light fruit sweetness emerges, while the lingering campfire smoke provides a warming conclusion. The complexity of the finish both surprises and delights.

Verdicts

Marcel

A whisky that immediately captivates with its smoky campfire aroma and salty sea breeze – here you can taste the wild soul of Islay. The Dun Naomhaig Bay Batch 1 is not a light dram, but a characterful one that’s great fun and tells new stories with every nosing.

Sascha

With a balanced blend of intense smokiness, fresh citrus notes, and complex spice, this Islay whisky reveals an impressive structure. The medium-length, salty-fruity finish rounds off the bottling with technical precision and confirms Feinkost Reifferscheid’s knack for harmonious single malts.

What it is worth

No auction record for this distillery, so we cannot tell you what this bottle is worth. We would rather say that than guess.

Source

Tasting note and scores by WHISKY:EDITION — tasted by Marcel and Sascha, published 2025-03-08.