Tasting notes

Dun Naomhaig Bay Batch 2 (2023) - Feinkost Reifferscheid

The 2023 Islay Single Malt Whisky, bottled by Feinkost Reifferscheid, is a characterful release without an age statement (No Age Statement), boasting a robust alcohol content of 56.0% ABV. As an independent bottler, Feinkost Reifferscheid has once again delivered a whisky that embodies the quintessential traits of the Isle of Islay.

The panel

Marcel
85
Sascha
86

Mean 85.5 · spread 1

Value for money 5/5

Bottler
Feinkost Reifferscheid
Type
Single Malt
Region
Isle of Islay
Country
Scotland
Strength
56% ABV
Character
peaty

Tasting

Nose

Upon the first nosing, a complex aroma unfolds. Grassy notes harmoniously blend with sweet honey and a hint of hemp. An intense campfire smoke, accompanied by bacon-like nuances and a touch of BBQ sauce, adds depth to the whisky. Subtle hints of red bell pepper and toasted breadcrumbs round off the bouquet.

Palate

On the palate, the whisky is full-bodied and creamy. Dominant cold smoke and ashy notes define the initial impression. This is followed by fruity hints of passion fruit, imparting a certain freshness to the taste. Notes of fresh hay and heather complement the flavor profile, ensuring a balanced interplay between smoke and freshness.

Finish

The finish is long-lasting, spicy, and marked by pronounced oak notes. A sensation reminiscent of smoldering coal lingers, while the whisky maintains an overall puristic character.

Verdicts

Marcel

A real crowd-pleaser for Islay fans: this whisky delivers bold smoke alongside a lovely fruitiness that leaves you wanting more. Despite the high alcohol content, it feels lively and not overbearing – a fantastic companion for cozy evenings by the fire.

Sascha

This bottling impresses with a clear structure where smoky and fruity elements harmonize in perfect balance. The long-lasting oak notes and its minimalist character make it a fine example of a complex Islay whisky with excellent balance.

What it is worth

No auction record for this distillery, so we cannot tell you what this bottle is worth. We would rather say that than guess.

Source

Tasting note and scores by WHISKY:EDITION — tasted by Marcel and Sascha, published 2025-03-09.