Tasting notes·Tobermory

Ledaig 16 Years (2005/2022) - Signatory Vintage

Ledaig - the smoky, wild brother of the Tobermory Distillery on the Isle of Mull.Anyone who knows Ledaig knows that there are no half measures here.The whisky is often intense, maritime and dirty - a kind of Islay alternative with its very own twist. The Ledaig 2005/2022 from Signatory Vintage takes this to the extreme.16 years of maturation and a stable 66.1% ABV - this is no gentle introduction to the world of peated whisky, but a real monster.The question is: does it deliver what the figures promise?

The panel

Marcel
85
Sascha
87

Mean 86.0 · spread 2

Value for money 0/5

Distillery
Tobermory
Bottler
Signatory Vintage
Type
Single Malt
Region
Isle of Mull
Country
Scotland
Age
16 years
Strength
66.1% ABV
Character
peaty

Tasting

Nose

It's clear from the first sniff: here comes a heavyweight.Bacon, barbecue smoke and maritime salt notes immediately dominate. It smells as if you are standing right next to a smoker grill on the coast, while the wind carries a mixture of charcoal and sea air. But there is more to this intense first impression. With a little time in the glass, BBQ sauce, honey and a hint of espresso unfold - a sweet and spicy depth that rounds off the flavour.The smoked almonds, which add a slightly nutty, oily note, are particularly exciting. And then there's that slightly earthy, dirty undertone that's so typical of Ledaig - as if you've just rolled your hands in wet peat. Fascinating and intense!

Palate

No surprise: at 66.1%, this whisky packs a punch. But despite the high alcohol strength, it is surprisingly complex. Voluminous, oily and powerful, it rolls over the tongue as if it were clawing its way into every corner of the mouth. The first impression is fruity and salty, almost as if you were tasting grilled peaches with a pinch of sea salt. But the BBQ wave sets in the very next moment: smoke, ham, charcoal, paired with a certain rubbery note and a slight hint of iodine. What makes it special: the flavours from the nose are perfectly reflected in the taste - nothing falls apart, nothing seems disharmonious. It does exactly what it is supposed to do, and with impressive intensity.

Finish

After such a brute start, one might expect a long, epic finish - but here the Ledaig surprises. Although the smoke remains noticeable, the finish is relatively short overall. What remains is a mixture of fruity and smoky notes, with a gentle echo of charcoal and salt.

Verdicts

Marcel

The Ledaig 2005/2022 is a wild ride for anyone who loves smoky power – the combo of BBQ, sea, and bacon really hits hard here. Despite a hefty 66.1%, it remains surprisingly approachable and just plain fun, even if the finish feels a bit too short. If you like it intense and full of character, this one will definitely deliver.

Sascha

This Ledaig impresses with its clear structure and the balance between maritime notes and smoky intensity at a proud 66.1% ABV. The aromas are precisely layered, the palate full-bodied and complex, with only the relatively short finish slightly detracting from the overall experience. A technically very well-crafted, robust single malt with a strong signature.

What it is worth

We do not yet hold bottle-level auction results — that sits behind Whisky Hunter’s authenticated feed. What follows is the market for Tobermory as a whole, which sets the weather for this bottling without pricing it.

£1£10£100£1k£10k2005200820112014201720202023

Latest mean bid £137 across 95 lots · 2024-08

Source

Tasting note and scores by WHISKY:EDITION — tasted by Marcel and Sascha, published 2025-04-20.